KENNESAW, Ga. (AP/Atlanta News First) — A Georgia judge on Monday ordered a temporary pause to a December execution that was already put on hold, saying questions about the state’s clemency process must be addressed before Stacey Humphreys’ death sentence could be carried out.

Humphreys, 52, was facing scheduled execution Dec. 17 but the procedure was paused just days before he was to have received a lethal injection.

He was convicted of malice murder and other crimes in the 2003 shooting deaths of Cyndi Williams, 33, and Lori Brown, 21, at the real estate office where they worked in Cobb County.

At issue: Humphreys’ lawyers contend that two members of Georgia’s parole board have conflicts of interest which would taint their participation in a clemency hearing.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Execution suspended for Georgia man convicted of murdering 2 women in Cobb County

Humphreys’ lawyers earlier this month filed a petition asking a judge to order the two members of the parole board to recuse themselves from considering his clemency petition.

The lawyers said one of those board members, Kimberly McCoy, was previously a victim advocate with the Cobb County district attorney’s office at the time of Humphreys’ trial and was assigned to work with victims in the case.

Another board member, Wayne Bennett, was the sheriff in Glynn County, where the trial was moved because of pretrial publicity. Humphreys’ lawyers say Bennett oversaw security for the jurors and Humphreys himself during the case.

In an order filed Monday, Fulton County Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney wrote that “pressing ‘pause’ on the execution machinery until we answer the non-frivolous question raised by Petitioner concerning the proper composition of the Board for his clemency hearing is the correct course of action.”

McBurney decided that Bennett’s disqualification from the board was not warranted.

The judge, however, still needs to decide whether McCoy should be replaced. He ruled that the board cannot proceed with Humphreys’ clemency application until he makes a final ruling on replacing McCoy with an interim board member or 90 days from Monday’s order.

He ordered lawyers for both sides to file additional legal briefs on the issue by Jan. 19.

Additionally, McBurney wrote in his order that Humphreys deserves to have the conflict of interest question researched and argued thoroughly so that a parole board free of conflicts of interest can decide his case at a clemency hearing.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE: Judge declines to halt execution of Georgia man seeking protection under pandemic agreement

Humphreys was convicted of fatally shooting Williams and Brown, who were working as real estate agents at the time, at a model home in 2003.

Prosecutors said Humphreys forced the women to strip and hand over their PINs before shooting them. He later admitted to investigators, “I know I did it.”

Humphreys withdrew more than $3,000 from the women’s bank accounts, according to court filings. He told police after his arrest that he had recently taken out some high-interest payday loans and needed money for a payment on his truck.

The state plans to use 5,000 milligrams of pentobarbital for the execution, which officials call a reliable method. Critics, however, warn that it can leave a person conscious and trapped inside their own body, describing the sensation as similar to drowning.

This is a developing story. Check back with Atlanta News First for updates.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE:

Lawyers argue agreement made during pandemic should shield Georgia man from execution

Opponents call for Georgia to rethink death penalty as state plans execution

Execution date set for man convicted of murdering 2 Cobb County real estate agents in 2003

Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. WANF contributed to this report.